As Harpo stated, I had a rock of
star polyp that did not open at all for over a month. All of my tests showed that the water condition was within acceptable limits, however I had allowed my salinity to creep up to about 1.027. This to me did not seem too far out of line, since I do not mix my water, I obtain it all from the ocean and I usually run in the neighorhood of 1.025-1.026. While doing a water change, I diluted with fresh water to reduce my salinity back down to 1.025. The next day the polyps were open and alive. They look better than ever now.
Don't know if this helps you, but hey, this is one of my very few success stories, so I have to tell it.
Bob