What do you mean a bucket? Was this pickling lime from the grocery store, or kalkwasser from a lfs?
If it is the former, you probably want a higher amount per gallon. According to Tom, he recommends 3 tablespoons per gallon. The idea is that the solution is saturated so it is the same no matter what the "bioload" of hard corals is.
You can start off with a lower amount, say 1 tsp per gallon, and follow your numbers, there is nothing wrong with that. Frankly I use 2 tsp per gallon of the
Kent Marine Kalkwasser, but next time I am going to get the much cheaper pickling lime, and dose it at higher concentrations.